Friday, December 4, 2009

The Biggest Mistake Media Companies Make Online

Yesterday, Media Industry News asked me three questions, one of which I shared with my Tweeps: What is the biggest mistake media companies make online? Nearly two dozen people weighed in with their own answers--and almost all of those responses are very good. Yet, I have my own take on this question that differs from most of the answers I received.

For all the talk about the importance of digital media, most traditional brands boast cultures, people, and processes that protect their dying assets (ie. print) at the expense of what is growing (ie. digital). There are a lot of reasons for this, and some of them are good ones. Print still brings in the vast majority of revenue. It somehow feeds in a more satisfying way the ego of editors and writers. And because the most resources are always devoted to the print product, the digital side remains a stepchild to the so-called main act--even when that act is unprofitable and dying.

As John Gardner once observed, most of the things that prevent the renewal of an organization can be found in the mind. It's not a matter of new ideas. "There is usually no shortage of new ideas," wrote Gardner in Self-Renewal. "The problem is to get a hearing for them. And that means breaking through the crusty rigidity and stubborn complacency of the status quo." Yet the rules, customs, and procedures in organizations always favor the past. That's why culture trumps strategy all the time. The cultural cues are that print (the past) is more important than digital (the future).

No traditional media player has a web-first culture, yet that is exactly what is needed to make an online operation really successful. It's another reason why newcomers have all the advantages in this game, and incumbents will never really get it. Sure, there are a lot of other mistakes media companies make online. But they aren't as fatal as the culture problem which leads to the protection of a high cost structure to support a dying medium and the refusal to embrace radical transformation.

My Tweeps offered up plenty of valid criticisms of traditional media's approach to digital.  I tend to think that Mike Duda, Michael Bigley and Chris Hardwick (see directly below) get closest to the truth. But that culture problem is a deal breaker. Others weigh in :
  • That online began as a stepchild and core people still are hanging on to the economics of "old" media and not embracing the reality or the opportunity of the web. @MikeDuda.
  • Media companies want their old business model to work online. It won't. They are failing. Pretty simple. From @michaelbigley.
  • Giving away product for free is biggest mistake. How can that ever be an effective business model? From @cjhardwick.
  • They focus too much on hits to the detriment of usability, e.g. having to click 20x to see the "Top 20" whatever. Usually abort after 3. From @ddudgeon
  • Failure to engage the audience as peers in real conversations the way people really talk to each other. (Failure to be real.) From @jterrito.
  • Shoveling stories from the paper to the screen and not considering the capability of the Web to tell a more complete story. From @annatauzin.
  • An us/them approach vs a community approach. From @littlebrownpen.
  • Not listening to what's being said in social media channels. Simply carrying broadcast mentality to a new channel. From @xybrewer.
  • Portals like My Yahoo offer customization. All others dump everything on us then expect us to sort it out - daily. No time for it. From @winequester.
  • Putting their content behind paywalls and not exposing it to search engines--and failure to take risks. From @jaybryant.
  • Poor reader targeting; trying to be everything to everyone; de-valuing their content by making all of it available for free. From @jeffschmitt.
  • They want to make rules, but they're immigrants to an existing community with existing standards. When in Rome..., etc. From @trymaster
  • Tweeting every headline they run. If I wanted RSS, I'd use RSS! From @lorakolodny.
  • The wholesale sacrifice of narrative in the name of being the first to break news. From @jpolicastro.
  • Using Facebook & Twitter but not using social media tools to reach their audiences in new, more effective ways. From @CPry
  • The single biggest mistake: not engaging audience enough. From @alexlcohen.
  • Not engaging their readers. Pursuing a monologue rather than a conversation. Which is the exact opposite of what you created at! From @GeriRosman.


  1. John,

    The biggest mistake is not recognizing that digital media fills the void in traditional media. It is impossible for direct marketers, newspapers, magazines, newsrooms, and all other one-way communicators to have real relationships with the people they serve. This has always given retailers an advantage over direct markers and gives newcomers an advantage over traditional media.

    While ignoring (or abhorring) digital media is a mistake, eliminating (or excluding) traditional is equally dangerous. The way we communicate is evolving. Some people want print media while others want digital. Some want to listen, while others want to exchange thoughts. Companies that want a sustainable business model will include all in their strategy.

    Traditional media companies have a distinct advantage over digital newcomers. They have brand awareness, historical data, established infrastructure, and customer loyalty. Digital media provides the tools to change one-way messaging into two-way communication. It's a shame that so few are using their good foundation to build a great business.

  2. Debra, thank you for a very thoughtful and substantive perspective. I agree that traditional media companies have brand awareness and customer loyalty on their side. But brand value and customer loyalty for media has been rapidly eroding since the peak year in 2000. There was a time when almost all media brands had so much value that they could have been leveraged to great advantage in the digital space. In many cases, brand equity has diminished to the point where it will not be able to make enough of a difference. So we agree that it is indeed a shame that so few brands are using or have used their "good foundation to build" great businesses.

  3. Mark Zuckerberg is onto something - and Loic Le Meur also gets it. I wrote about it here ("On the Web is Freedom 2, Publishing 0"):

    :) nmw

  4. Please do, though, notice the "community" strain that connects several of these comments.

    The "existing standards" to which I refer (the Rome where this all is happening) involve the very concept of community on the web. If it has escaped anybody's notice, please be aware that community is paramount on the web.

    Thus I see @jterrito, @littlebrownpen, @xybrewer, me, @CPry, @alexlcohen and @GeriRosman as all basically saying the same thing. I don't know @MikeDuda, so I can only say that to my reading, this community approach is "the reality and opportunity" to which he refers.

    Clearly I disagree with @cjhardwick and @jeffschmitt say. And, again, note that it is a minority view at least on this page. I agree that publishing for 'free' is "a problem". I just don't think it's "the problem".

    And I totally get how the whole Google thing makes people's brains short-circuit. What Goog does is deeply, deeply counterintuitive to traditional media. But also highly profitable.

    I reject out-of-hand the assertion that Google is profiting from others' content. Rather, I say that Google profits from connecting users to content. It is a service that most web publishers appreciate greatly. Google, unlike any other search engine ever, goes to great pains to deliver the least-skewed results possible. Google is constantly on the hunt for people who game their system. That's why they succeed.

    There is a direct connection between Google's user-centric, community-oriented approach and their financial success. And Jarvis is right - do what Google would do.

    (For the record, y'all should know that this blog is built on the Blogger platform, provided for free by Google.)

    I don't envy the pain the papes are going through, and all media for that matter. But it's hard to be sympathetic when we - the existing web community - have been offering this same advice for, Jeezum, a decade now. At some point, these new-coming media companies have to admit that we, also, are grown ups.

    I leave you with a single link - also to test how your blog handles html tags - that everybody who takes this issue seriously must follow: Cluetrain. Read it, love it, live it.

    Thanks for the provocative post, and best luck with your new venture.

  5. John,

    Excellent post. While you appear to be focusing on traditonal print media, you could easily replace all your references to print with 'broadcast' and their stubborn desire to hang on to analog to the detriment of digital. I've seen first-hand the lack of 'web-first' cultures and what that does to the digital side.


  6. You'll find it contains a lesser bank to the opposing section. A Zuma Mulberry Travelling bag is rather comfortable plus chanel outlet a wrist strap discuss a person's arm seriously good. The medial the following Mulberry Travelling bag is actually a less harsh pad clothing by using gucci replica openings for frequently section plus its seriously roomy. Them maintains each of this personal needs. It's actually not the main mulberry profit I possibly found, however continue to maintains such a large amount. Alternative benefits your website return hublot replica near drawing a line under (this visits near! )#), plus minimal stainless steel "things" to the backside of your Zuma Mulberry Travelling bag it would not majority and incapacitated. The key reason why get Chanel Mulberry Travelling bag Internet, you can check with? And also never. A mulberry baggage profit want couple of AA energy for any lumination. A lumination is definitely started up and also out of hermes replica if initial plus ending a travelling bag as a result of a magnets control key. Virtually no stress, you simply will not light up a total home with the Mulberry purses and handbags, it is really just enough to seek out just what exactly you are looking at in the travelling bag. A Mulberry handThe Mulberry purses and handbags boast on the level of quality. Every last Mulberry travelling bag is made from the finest level of quality set plus chanel replica 2.55 puppy stash consequently building these folks standout while in the market with one hundred dollars alternative creator music labels.

  7. In conclusion we can say that an undergrad auto credit is the way to satisfy your auto dreams.Concerning people in Jacksonville, FL with poor credit, its difficult to find an Auto title loans

  8. Whatever the issue or crisis was or is, borrowers request no credit check advances. There is a requirement for quick money. Did the spiraling spending plan start before or after the advance was handled, affirmed and stored into the bank? Moment cash notices snappy money help, yet with no consideration paid to how to give back the cash, things can and will get distressing. payday loans chicago

  9. Today, the country over, numerous individuals are keen on Texas home loan advances. This is on the grounds that the state laws of Texas offer some a bigger number of advantages to credit purchasers than other state laws. There are more than 400 home loan giving organizations in Texas. They offer first home loans, second home loans and home loan renegotiating credits at low intrigue rates. auto title loans

  10. In the event that there are different choices for you to get a credit with ghastly credit, verify that you consider those right now whether a vehicle title improvement is the best answer at this moment. Other snappy money sort advances unite; unsecured individual credits, payday credit credits, ensured payday advances, quick business credits and secured individual credit drives. Cash Advance San-diego

  11. Along these lines, there will be no miracles concerning paying back your credit without aggravates. Keep in mind that unmistakable individuals utilizing vehicle title credits are doing this if all else fails or as a transient reaction for getting brilliant money, and you completely would support not to get included with any budgetary commute capable who could mistreat your cash related condition. You ought to dependably pursue down the relationship of particular specialists for genuine, record and appraisal course before you sign anything. Check Cashing

  12. There is ignored danger in the yearly business reach, and moneylenders are instructing for candidate thought. The included requesting you ask, the more fundamental would be your technique. Payday Loans

  13. Phân phối MBland Central Point Trung Kính | Mở bán CT1A, CT1B Nghĩa Đô | Thông tin chung cư 84 Thợ Nhuộm | Bán Eco Green City Nguyễn Xiển | Thông tin Hòa Bình Green City | Phân phối chung cư Gemek Premium | Bán Tây Hà Tower | Thông tin chung cư 89 Phùng Hưng | Mở bán chung cư PCC1 Complex Hà Đông | Tin tức Liền kề Thành Phố Giao Lưu | Bán Liền Kề Mon City | Tin tức Liền Kề GoldSilk Complex Hà Đông | Thông tin Chung cư Golden Land 275 Nguyễn Trãi | Bán chung cư Green Pearl 378 Minh Khai | Thông tin chung cư e4 tower yên hòa Cầu Giấy | Phân phối Vinhomes Gardenia Mỹ Đình | Mở bán chung cư Udic Riverside 122 Vĩnh Tuy Hà Nội | Thông tin Vinhomes Phạm Hùng Cầu Giấy | Tin tức Gemek Premium Hoài Đức

    You will easily connect with investors, real estate agencies, brokers, customers, .... when using the communication channels leading Real Estate Vietnam. APARTMENT INFORMATION - Information channel No. 1 Hanoi apartment!!!

  14. chung cư Vinata Tower sắp ra hàng | dự án chung cư Vinata Tower 289 Khuất Duy Tiến mở bán | Chung cư Vinata Tower 289 Khuất Duy Tiến ra hàng đợt 1 | Chung cư Oriental Plaza mặt đường Láng Hạ |dự án chung cư Oriental Plaza 16 Láng Hạ có hàng | chung cư Oriental Plaza 16 Láng Hạ có bảng hàng | chung cư Petrowaco | chung cư Petrowaco 97-99 Láng Hạ Hà Nội | chung cư Petrowaco 97-99 Láng Hạ ra mắt thị trường | chung cư 97-99 Láng Hạ có hàng hợt 1 | Bán đợt 2 dự án Chung cư mon City Mỹ Đình | Ra hàng mới chung cư Mon City Mỹ Đình | Bán chung cư HD Mon City Mỹ Đình | Mon City Mỹ Đình có bảng hàng chính thức | ra bảng hàng mới dự án chung cư Eco Green City Nguyễn Xiển| Eco Green City căn hộ đảng cấp | chung cư Eco Green City Nguyễn Xiển ra hàng đợt 1 | Chung cư Imperial Plaza 360 Giải Phóng | chung cư 360 Giải Phóng chuẩn bị ra hàng| dự án Chung cư Valencia Garden Long Biên mở bán đợt 1 | Dự án chung cư Hải Đăng Tower 29 Láng Hạ sắp mở bán | chung cư Hải Đăng Tower có hàng đợt 1| Chung cư 29 Láng Hạ có hàng mới | Chung cư Mandarin Garden 2 Hòa Phát Tân Mai sắp ra mắt | Chung cư Mandarin Garden 2 sắp mở bán | Chung cư 493 Trương Định Tân Mai | Triển khai Chung cư Ecolife Tây Hồ Viện Kiểm Soát | Ecolife Tây Hồ sắp ra mắt thị trường bđs| Chung cư 360 Giải Phóng chuẩn bị ra mắt thị trường|Chung cư Paragon Tower có hàng đợt 2| Paragon Tower ra bảng hàng đợt 1.

  15. Contrary to what you may accept been told in the past, payday loans are absolutely a cheaper agency of absolute funds for bodies who may accept contrarily had to acquisition an alternate, beneath desirable, and added big-ticket option. For instance, a payday accommodation fee is about beneath big-ticket than a coffer defalcation fee.
    payday loans

  16. For instance, a payday accommodation fee is about beneath big-ticket than a coffer defalcation fee. They are additionally usually cheaper than a archetypal acclaim agenda "over-the-limit" fee and about beneath big-ticket than the costs associated with abating a account that would accept contrarily been revoked - such as a utilities reconnection or backward fee.
    car title loans


  17. Increasing annoyance amid borrowers for assorted lending companies is a arresting acumen for arising aloft mentioned guidelines. The government's accommodation is a absorption of its will to accept a accurate and cellophane arrangement for the business. There are abounding shortcomings in present arrangement that can be adapted alone with the appropriate access and by authoritative bright rules.
    Check Cashing Corona

  18. Before accepting this blazon of agenda or alike application your banknote beforehand again anticipate aboriginal if you could handle the absorption that they are activity to accord you. See if you could allow to pay for it if you are not abiding again bigger not use your beforehand for it is added big-ticket than by aloof application your agenda to acquirement something.

    payday loans

  19. The industry is abounding with average man companies that acquire no absolute lending capabilities, but serve to aggregate data, such as your information, and berry it to assorted no acclaim analysis accommodation companies for a nominal fee.
    Cash Advance Chicago

  20. Any loan resulting in a release of cash during times of immediate financial crises would be termed as best payday loan. It is only after the purpose for which the loan was taken gets satisfied that we start thinking critically of the loan. It will be wrong to term this tendency as selfishness.
    check cashing near me

  21. hanks for the best was very useful for me.keep sharing such idea
    s in the future as well.this was actually what i was looking for,and i
    am glad to came here
    earn to die 3
    game hot earn to die 3
    Hi! I’ve been reading your blog for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give youu a shout out from Austin Texas! Just wanted to tell you keep up the fantastic work!my weblog
    game hot tank trouble 3
    game tank trouble

  22. This is the game is played so great. Invite you to experience it interesting things there.
    strike force heroes | strike force heroes 4 | age of war | happy wheels | tank trouble 2

    With a Hotmail account, you can send and receive emails quickly and easily as well as login and use all Microsoft services.
    sign in to gmail | log in to gmail

    hotmail sign in | hotmail login

  23. Also, when I look genuine close I discover botches, I once found the name of another organization, and it was clearly a cut-and-glue work. Excessively occupied with, making it impossible to do it right I presume. You can envision how resentful I was seeing as I was paying $350 a hour to an establishment lawyer to help me take care of my divulgence records. car title loans chicago

  24. As you search for individual credits you can rest guaranteed that you won't need to set up any sort of security. Secured credits require a lien against your home, auto, watercraft, or property. This implies in the event that you can't reimburse the advance on the moneylender's calendar, the bank has the legitimate ideal to take away your property as installment. check cashing

  25. To begin with thing you need to know is insights about home value advance. Likewise it is a technique for having fund where a home seeker obtains sum, i.e. he looks for a sum which is the distinction among the market rate of the house and the sum that he needs as yet having a unique home loan if there is any. cash advance

  26. SOR pegged loan costs have a tendency to vacillate more since it responds to the continually changing remote coin trade rates. Hence, SIBOR is esteemed as more steady when contrasted with SOR. auto title loans

  27. It may appear to be sufficiently simple to see however you truly need to delve into the points of interest to get an intensive appreciation. Here are the absolute most essential things you have to know. Cash Advance

  28. Keep in mind to continue paying off your present credits until your new bank and finished the procedure. A decent bank will have client agents that will be in contact with you with any upgrades. payday loans

  29. One downside with government credits is that the quantity of advances accessible is topped, with applications waiting be submitted ahead of schedule to guarantee endorsement.

  30. الان مع افضل ما توصل له علم الديكورات الحديث من تصميمات نقدم لكم جماليات ورق جدران ثلاثى الابعاد بطلائاتها الجديدة لمنتجات ورق جدران ثلاثي الابعاد فى الرياض فالان ان كنت بمرحلة الانشاء لمنزلك وترغب فى تصميم افضل الديكورات بمنزلك واختيار افضل دهانات الحوائط او ورق حائط ثلاثي الابعاد و ورق الجدران لغرف النوم وايضا دهانات دكتور بينت فكل انواع الدهانات الحديثة نقدمها لكم عملائنا الكرام .

    نحن نقدم كل جديد فى عالم الديكورات ونوفر لكم ورق جدران للمطبخ وللصالات بافضل استايل وخاص فقط بنا وبجودة عالية جدا ولكل من يبحث عن الرقى والجودة فنحن نقدمها لك باقل الاسعار وبافضل الخامات للارضيات والحوائط وكافة اعمال الديكورات ونقدم لعملائنا التى تم التعامل معهم افضل انواع الديكورات مثل ورق الجدران ثلاثى الابعاد بالرياض وبجدة وبالدمام الذي يجعل منزلك قطعة من لوحة فنية .

  31. This comment has been removed by the author.

  32. Última cotação do apartamento Emerald em junho de 2017
    Atualizado a mais recente cotação de apartamentos An Binh em junho / 2017.
    No início de junho de 2017, o preço dos apartamentos é de aproximadamente 29 milhões / m2 - 35 milhões / m2, dependendo da área, direção do apartamento e localização do piso. Todos podem se referir à citação abaixo para fazer a escolha de apartamentos mais adequada.
    Entre em contato conosco: 0963 172 723 para detalhes de cada apartamento preço nhé
    Com o preço de venda é muito bom e competitivo no mercado com uma variedade de utilidades, bela localização O apartamento esmeralda para o momento é muito atraente para os clientes e tópico quente. Mercado imobiliário.
    Os clientes são elegíveis para avançar 20 milhões para escolher o apartamento de acordo com suas necessidades e preferências.
    - O preço oficial anunciado pelo proprietário em 24/05/2017, os clientes arruinaram a escolha para seus belos apartamentos com preços razoáveis.
    Seja o cliente inteligente ao escolher sua própria casa através do projeto do apartamento esmeralda!
    Se você ainda tem problemas como questões legais ou procedimentos para pedir o apartamento, fique assegurado, o motivo é que nosso projeto foi 100% legal e foi pedido por muitos residentes. Ok então
    Além disso, este é um bom lugar para que os investidores sábios se juntem, de acordo com os nossos registros, há muitos haneses que vivem e alugam apartamentos na área a preços muito altos. Se você é um investidor inteligente, você deve optar por investir no projeto esmeralda.

  33. For getting a higher exposure for your facebook account, People spend money to Buy Facebook Followers to very easily obtain exposure on world-wide-web. buy facebook followers

  34. عزيزي العميل عندما يتم اللجوء الى شركة نقل اثاث بالخبر فتاكد ان عملية النقل سوف تكون ممتازة نتيجة الى ان الشركة تقوم بالتحديث من مهامها كل فترة حتى تتماشي مع الأسلوب العالمي فى النقل ومن ضمن الخدمات المستحدثة استبدال السيارات القديمة والحديثة حيث ان سيارات نقل عفش بالدمام مجهزة تماما لنقل اي كمية من الاثاث شركه نقل عفش بالاحساء
    شركه نقل عفش بالجبيل
    السعر الرخيص لس فى كل الأحيان دليل على ان الخدمة المقدمة ليست عالية المستوى ولكن توجد عدد من الشركات تقوم بتحجيم الاسعار نتيجة الى الحالة المعيشية والاقتصادية السائدة فى المجتمع ومن ضمن تلك الشركات ارخص شركة نقل العفش بالاحساء شركه نقل عفش بالقطيف
    شركة نقل عفش بالخبر

  35. Business banks offer various administrations to their clients, however as of late, numerous individuals have utilized check getting the money for administrations rather than banks, check cashing near me open now san diego

  36. ارخص شركة شحن عفش

    نقل عفش من جدة الى مكة نقل عفش من جدة الى مكة
    شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى الامارات نقل عفش من جدة الى الامارات
    افضل شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى الرياض نقل عفش من جدة الى الرياض
    شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى الدمام نقل عفش من جدة الى الدمام
    شركة نقل عفش من المدينة المنورة الى مكة نقل عفش من المدينة المنورة الى مكة

  37. Maintain up the excellent work in future also, I check out a few articles on this website, including I take into consideration that your topics posts is fascinating and has sets of amazing item of details. Thanks for your valuable initiatives. australia assignment -
    Assignment Help in Melbourne -
    Assignment Help Perth

  38. I do believe all of the suggestions you have introduced on your article content. They’re really convincing and will definitely work. This amazing site is one thing that is needed on the internet, the many releases are very quick for beginners. essay assignment help - economics assignment help - marketing assignment help

  39. Nice Post...
    My Hp Printer Is Offline - HP Printer Issues Resolved
    When you try to print anything from your printer, the task is assigned to the default printer set on your computer. Unless the default printer is your HP printer or unless you change the settings manually every time, your printing tasks will be assigned to another printer. This is why you might not be able to print and can’t move past “Why My HP Printer Is Offline”. So, what should you do to fix this issue? Well, the answer is After setting up your printer as default you can try printing again. Your issue must be resolved. However, if it does persist, try other solutions like re-establishing the printer connection. Reading your printer to the computer, updating drivers, etc.

  40. Assignment help in Saudi Arabia allows students to finish their papers on time without having any mistakes. If you want to submit error-free papers in your universities, you must think about online assignment help in Saudi Arabia.

  41. Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thank you However I am experiencing issue with ur rss. Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx
    Click Here
    Visit Web

  42. You have a great blog here! would you like to make some invite posts on my blog?
    Click Here

  43. Surfing the valuable and industry oriented content is my choice. That’s why I am internet savvy to know to dig out the amazing piece to increase our experience. Our Assignment Help service chain is doing the best approach to let reflect valuable content effort in their work.

  44. Great Post! We are the ones who can provide you the best help and solutions to your RR Login issue and other roadrunner email services issue.

  45. We are a top rated PUBH2004 Online service here with experts specializing in a wide range of disciplines ensuring you get the assignments that score maximum grades.

  46. Great post. i am here to tell you about dissertation writing. As someone who has worked with several dissertation experts, I can attest to the quality of these professionals.

  47. If you looking for a reliable plumber Hoppers Crossing, look no further than NLK Plumbing. The staff here are experienced and can help you with any plumbing problem you have. Call us today @ 0404 803 333.


  48. Thank you for sharing this informative blog with us. Your blog is very useful for us. If yor are looking for Homework help in Australia. So, Homework Help in Australia is a service that helps students with their schoolwork. It's like having a friendly guide who can explain things and give you tips to make your homework easier. Whether you're struggling with math, science, writing, or any other subject, these services are there to support you. They can provide explanations, answer questions, and offer examples to help you understand your assignments better. So, if you ever find yourself stuck with your homework in Australia, don't worry – there's help available to make learning and studying a bit less challenging.